Close Menu
Human Resources Mag
  • Home
  • News
  • Management
  • Guides
  • Law
  • Talents
  • Benfits
  • Technology
  • More
    • Web Stories
    • Editor’s Picks
    • Press Release
What's On

Nova Scotia updates severance rules for non-union public workers

July 3, 2025

Worker challenges temporary layoff provision as part of unenforceable termination provision

July 3, 2025

Menopause ‘penalty’ pushing women out of workplace: study

July 3, 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Human Resources Mag
Subscribe
  • Home
  • News
  • Management
  • Guides
  • Law
  • Talents
  • Benfits
  • Technology
  • More
    • Web Stories
    • Editor’s Picks
    • Press Release
Human Resources Mag
Home » A Snapshot Look At The Ugly Side Of HR (Most Are Surprised When They Learn These Things)
Benfits

A Snapshot Look At The Ugly Side Of HR (Most Are Surprised When They Learn These Things)

staffBy staffMay 17, 20255 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Copy Link LinkedIn Tumblr Email Telegram WhatsApp
Follow Us
Google News Flipboard
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

All great corporate functions treat criticism as an opportunity for improvement, but not HR. 

After decades in HR, I have learned that our typical response to any form of criticism is not to welcome it. But instead, to instantly create a never-ending array of denials and excuses. And therefore, the purpose of this article is to test whether the following “bad news data points” will drive more solutions or more excuses.

HR champions retention, but HR has the highest turnover rate of all functions

For years, HR has been emphasizing the tremendous dollar damage created by employee turnover. So it is somewhat embarrassing to learn that LinkedIn data revealed that HR’s employee turnover rate is by far the highest among all corporate functions. HR’s turnover is 38% higher than the average corporate function turnover rate and 11% higher than the next-worst turnover function (research and development).

HR champions diversity, but it has the lowest rate of gender diversity

For years, HR has been the recognized champion of gender, racial, and national origin diversity. However, researchers have concluded that “most DEI programs don’t work.” And when it comes to gender diversity, men are seriously underrepresented because 71% of HR professionals are women (Namely’s HR Careers Report), and 65 % of HR professionals identify as white.

HR champions pay equity, but it doesn’t practice it

Namely, research found that male HR professionals earn 13% more than HR women. And that means that the pay rate for women in HR is only 89% of what male HR professionals are paid, which is only a slight improvement over the 84% national pay differential.

Despite years of trying, HR still isn’t rated as strategic

Even though it’s an almost universal goal for HR to become strategic. Over the decades, HR has literally never convinced a majority of business leaders to rate it as strategic. And the strategic rating for function is, unfortunately, a full 21 points behind the rating that finance receives.

Despite all our efforts, HR is still not trusted by employees

Being fully trusted by your own customers is also a major strategic goal at every HR function. However, a survey of major corporations (in tech) found that 70% of our employees don’t trust us. And among these 18 top companies, not a single company can report that a majority of its employees trust HR at their company.

Many of HR’s primary programs (recruiting, development, and wellness) have painfully high failure rates

Recruiting, the HR function with the highest business impact, has a painful new-hire failure rate of 46%. The learning and development sub-function, which is among the biggest spenders in the HR budget, has data that reveals that an amazing 90% of individual L&D programs fail to reach their targeted outcomes. And as a result, 75% of managers report that they are dissatisfied with their L&D function. Another costly HR program covers wellness benefits. However, when program impact data was collected on the effectiveness of 90 different wellness programs, the results were disappointing. The data revealed that the employees who participated in any of the available 90 wellness programs ended up being no better off than their colleagues who never used a single one of them (source: New York Times)


Calculating the dollar impact of each HR program on strategic business goals is the answer to turning failure around

I have found that program failures aren’t quickly identified in HR because so many HR subfunctions purposely avoid calculating or discussing their failure rates. The overriding reason why high failure rates are allowed to go on is that the costs of HR failures are never converted into their dollar impact on business goals.

The overriding principle in corporate America is that things that make (or cost) large amounts of money get immediate and constant attention from senior executives. For example, if executives at Google knew that the loss of a single top innovator engineer as a result of weak recruiting or ineffective retention was up to 300 times their annual salary, recruiting and retention failures would quickly be identified and fixed, or heads would roll.

To executives, it’s always about the money. Yet, for some reason, HR executives universally fail to calculate and report their function’s dollar impact on business goals.

Note: You can learn details about how to calculate the dollar impact of an HR program here.

“Criticism should be HR’s engine of change.”

Final Thoughts

In today’s fast-changing world, criticism must be treated as an opportunity to learn that can’t be missed. So you should treat the criticism that you receive as a chance to receive free objective feedback from internal supporters, outsiders, and your users. Using criticism will help to keep your team’s egos in check while at the same time avoiding groupthink. And finally, you should realize that criticism forces your team to respond to issues with data, instead of opinions. 

I have found that smart talent leaders, rather than being suspicious or angry, actively seek out data that may reveal their failures. And make it as easy as possible for colleagues, outsiders and your users to anonymously criticize your work, your solutions, and your plans! 

Note: You can learn more about additional high-impact HR programs that almost universally need improvement here.

Thank you for reading.

Note to the reader
Please take the time to follow Dr. Sullivan or to request a connection with him on LinkedIn.
And please help spread his ideas by sharing this with your team/network and by posting it on your favorite social media.

Follow on Google News Follow on Flipboard
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Copy Link

Related Articles

What Is Global Human Resource Management (GHRM)?

July 3, 2025 Benfits

AI agent adoption is lagging. Experts explain what HR can do

July 3, 2025 Benfits

A Look at the Future of Hiring

July 2, 2025 Benfits

Record high reached for workplace discrimination, harassment and retaliation claims

July 2, 2025 Benfits

Top companies prioritize skill velocity over depth as AI technology evolves rapidly and changes workplaces along the way

July 1, 2025 Benfits

As July 4 boosts PTO requests, how tech can assist

July 1, 2025 Benfits
Top Articles

Accused of fraud, murder, fired exec awarded $500,000, 24 months’ notice

January 9, 202498 Views

5 Best Learning Management Systems in 2025

February 11, 202591 Views

Canadian Tire store under investigation for alleged exploitation of temporary foreign workers

October 2, 202491 Views
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
  • WhatsApp
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
Latest News

AI agent adoption is lagging. Experts explain what HR can do

staffJuly 3, 2025

Woman employee at Infosys exposes harassment attempt, leads to arrest and internal review —

staffJuly 3, 2025

How to avoid constructive dismissal claims with temporary layoffs

staffJuly 2, 2025
Most Popular

Nova Scotia updates severance rules for non-union public workers

July 3, 20250 Views

Worker challenges temporary layoff provision as part of unenforceable termination provision

July 3, 20250 Views

Menopause ‘penalty’ pushing women out of workplace: study

July 3, 20250 Views
Our Picks

AI agent adoption is lagging. Experts explain what HR can do

July 3, 2025

Woman employee at Infosys exposes harassment attempt, leads to arrest and internal review —

July 3, 2025

How to avoid constructive dismissal claims with temporary layoffs

July 2, 2025

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest human resources news and updates directly to your inbox.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
© 2025 Human Resources Mag. All Rights Reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.